Jorge Correia Orfão
Master in Feminist Studies
FLUC
Seminário de Ficção, Memória e História
February the 4th of 2011
Transgender history should allow the gender ambiguous to speak (…) necessary because without
such histories, we are left with only a bare trace of a life lived in defiance of gender norms.
(Halberstam 2005: 49)
Abstract
The following essay is based on Jackie Kay’s novel, Trumpet (1998), winner of the Guardian Fiction Prize. I will attempt to explore to what extent does the prefix “trans-” disrupt our conventional categories of gender and sexuality, and to what extent does it reinforce them. Showing how the different characters of the novel speak about Joss and Millie Moody’s “secret”, I will try to demonstrate how identity is constructed or “performed”. The essay draws on Michel Foucault’s “discursive fact” theory that illustrates “the regime of power-knowledge-pleasure that sustains the discourse on human sexuality” (Foucault 1998/1978: 11). His discussion about gender and sexuality will help us reflect about what post-foucaultian queer theorists have to say about such issues.
Queer theorist, Judith Butler, presents a scheme that involves the distinction between performance and “performativity” (Butler 1990). Considering the fact that “heterosexuality” is legitimized as the norm, the idea of “heteronormativity” will help justify the subjectivity “discourses” may assume. This will help to account for Judith Halberstam’s discussion about the transgender life. She explains the motivations to read and/or write about the transgender subject. Summarizing Jay Prosser’s transgender theories, Halberstam underlines Prosser’s critic towards the theory of “performativity”. Her argumentations will suggest a distinction between “the real” and the “realness” of individuals like Joss Moody. I will report to how the “realness” of Joss’s identity is “(re)presented” and interpreted. By remembering the life of the main character, core ideas in the history and development of gender studies and gender theory are examined in each section of the essay.
The essay presents eight sections in which different theorists will be mentioned. Each section comments on a theoretical topic that has its own contribution in the continuing development of queer theory/theories. Such theories have approached relevant social issues that help explain how gender and sexuality is being managed within communities. Each section introduces a topic that requires further studies. What is important to note is the fact that, if we link each topic presented, it will help support the response to what I am aiming to explore, when one thinks about the transgender subject. The interpretation of the novel I propose, seeks to evaluate how queer theory can be analyzed through literature. This will enhance the idea that through literature, sociological approaches can be evaluated and expanded. (...)
in red: revision/reediting needed